E-MAIL TO DR SING DATED MAR 30, 2011 FROM AN AMERICAN
VOLUNTEER
FOR HIS OLD UNIVERSITY FOR SCHOLARSHIP SELECTION OF ONE SINGAPOREAN
Thanks so much for taking the
time to talk to .... yesterday. You gave her a great deal of
good information. I support your advice to her to think
carefully about her career choices. A clever interviewer will be
alert to people who are not serious and are simply fishing for
some way to pay their university tuition. |
MY COMMENTS
The girl from a brand-name school, Raffles Institution could easily
get into the top colleges in the U.S, U.K or Australia. A great number
of her cohort of 1000 would probably get 3As but she has 6As. That was
an excellent academic achievement.
It opens doors to any scholarship but she was the only candidate with
Science and Maths amongst seven short-listed for a US scholarship
interview. The scholarship was for a liberal arts degree in a US
university which the volunteer told me is a sister school of Williams
College attended by Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong. When well known
names are thrown in, it gets attention of the other party
So this girl attended would have got Wesleyan Freeman Asian
Scholarship if she would study Political Science, according to the
volunteer whom I shall call Mr Baker.
Mr Baker was a volunteer but not an interviewer for his University
which would offer 1 scholarship for each of the 11 Asian countries. I
believed that this girl was top choice but she wanted to study
Veterinary Science. Mr Baker said: "Political science is not
veterinary science". He emailed to me to ask me if I would advise this
girl by phone. Instead I advised meeting as phone calls were a waste
of time if one is to advise a bright young lady on her career (as a
volunteer).
Mr Baker arrived early by cycling from Clementi to Toa Payoh as I
discovered later. I was surprised. "You must be one of those crazy and
eccentric Ang Mos (Caucasians)," I was wondering how he could arrive
at Toa Payoh Vets without sweat and how dangerous it was to cycle so
far. I must say he was lean and fit at the age of 50 and could put
many a younger 40-year-old man to shame in fitness.
The young lady arrived in a taxi on time. As my surgery was small in
space, I suggested we had a talk at the coffee shop behind. A
bespectacled fair lady with long bronze gold hair and of pleasant
first impressions. We sat and Mr Baker offered to buy drinks though
initially he planned to introduce us and go home. I insisted that he
stay to "chaperone" me, not that I need one as it was a public place.
Mr Baker with his receding forehead and baldness presents an energetic
intelligent appearance and is the type who does not want to take up
too much of my time.
Our talk lasted around 2 hours as Mr Baker offered to buy lunch too.
We ate at the coffeeshop. So was this scholarly lady passionate about
veterinary medicine? She has a dog. But not one substantial piece of
evidence that she had cared for animals at the SPCA, veterinary
surgeries or animal welfare groups or any activity related to animals
in Singapore.
Her parents wanted her to study medicine or law as they considered
veterinary medicine dirty. In any case, they can't support her to
study veterinary medicine overseas and therefore she has to get a
scholarship. In this modern age and in a developed modern Singapore,
there are still Singapore parents who want their progeny to fulfill
their dreams of not being able to become a doctor or lawyer! And to
consider veterinary medicine as dirty! In the UK where I studied some
40 years ago, the demand for veterinary studies far exceed the demand
to study medicine and I believe this is the situation in the U.S!
Here, we have Singaporean parents looking down at a superstar academic
who wants to study veterinary medicine.
Will she get the AVA veterinary scholarship? The 6As will get her into
past the door into the interview room as this was what must have
happened at the US university interview she attended recently.
Academic excellence still give the best cherries despite some
Singapore parents talking about over-stressing their children and
asking for less pressure of homework in the Singapore tuition and
education hot bed.
"But the AVA is looking for regulators and enforcers to check on far
away farms in China and other countries to accredit them for export of
meat to Singapore," I said to this girl. "SVA is not looking for
practitioners in small or large animal medicine. You look kind of
delicate," I said. She had said she was interested in farm practice
with the large animals. Most vets have run away from rural veterinary
practice and here she wanted to do that.
Typically and stereotypically, most bright Singaporean lady scholars
completing their A levels spend most time studying very hard and
therefore they are fair and delicate looking. At least those few
ladies who applied for internship with me gave me this impression.
Will she get the AVA scholarship? She had to write 2 articles. What
was her most important achievement and why she wanted to study vet
medicine? Without supporting evidence, I wonder how she wrote about in
the 2nd article required by AVA?
We hope she will get the scholarship. The kind gentleman aged 50 gave
some advices like student loans, working for a few years first. He got
a scholarship from the GI bill which provides scholarship for
Americans who had served in the US Army. I thought he was the average
man as he had retired and had said during our meeting: "I have one
foot in the grave". Men who are past 50 and who tells me they have one
foot in the grave don't impress me.
I said to this kind gentleman who is actually a top scholar at Harvard
or some top US university and an inventor in military engineering
after I asked him more about his background: "If you have one foot in
the grave at the age of 50 years, I must be having one and a half foot
in the grave as I am 60 years old!" Men who are in their 50s do think
that way. I wonder if women of similar age do think similarly?
I say he is a kind man because he spent time to help this stranger, a
girl with 6As to know more about veterinary science by contacting me.
He was not happy with the interviewers of his old school wanting to
direct this girl to study political science and thereby giving her the
scholarship. Americans are always brutally honest and into your face
if they like some behaviour?
In the end, the scholarship went to another girl and from what I know,
this girl had the passion for the arts which included writing,
literature and education as I was told that this girl with fuzzy hair
(I think it was fuzzy hair) gave education classes at the School of
Thought. Have you ever heard of such a school or have I got the wrong
name?
Political science is far removed from veterinary science. But I would
take the political science scholarship if I have 6As and study in the
US. Excel in this scholarship and then get a scholarship to become a
veterinarian if my parents have no money to sponsor me. After all, how
many young Singaporeans can have a chance to study in a top liberal
arts school in the US?
If a young adult has passion in veterinary medicine and the parents
don't have the S$300,000 to pay the tuition fees, taking this US
scholarship will broaden her mind and make him a better all rounded
veterinarian if she studies vet medicine as a mature student.
But a lady with 6 straight As can have her pick of scholarships. So
what if she can't get the AVA scholarship? She has others. So, does
she have the passion for veterinary medicine or not? Was she fishing
for the best scholarship? Most of her 100 friends in Raffles
Institution want to be doctors and so I expect lesser competition for
her.
Based on her lack of animal activism veterinary and welfare work in
her past years at Raffles Institution, it would be hard for her to get
the AVA scholarship if there are others with track records.
P.S
1. According to the kind gentleman, the Wesleyan Freeman Asian
Scholarship Program provides expenses for a 4-year course to study
"Political Science", not "Veterinary Science" for one exceptionally
able Asian student annually from one Asian country. So, he was quite
pissed off when the interviewers asked this girl to study Political
Science instead, did some research and e-mailed to me to advise her
about veterinary medicine.
In any case, the Wesleyan University, Middletown, Connecticut provides
a liberal arts education. The Freeman Foundation provides the
scholarship. Sadly, he told me that Mr Freeman, an original founder of
AIG group has just passed away.
Selection criteria included academic achievement, intellectual
curiosity, a high level of discipline and commitment, strong personal
qualities, extracurricular involvement especially community service
and English language ability.
2. Williams College, a highly selective private liberal arts college,
Massachusetts.
3. Volunteerism is human kindness. Mr Baker is not paid by his
University. In fact, he paid for the drinks and lunch. Volunteerism
also open doors to meet other people when you help somebody.
4. Mr Baker appeared fresh and clean after cycling from Clementi to
Toa Payoh because he changed his clothes at the Toa Payoh Swimming
Pool. He has 3 engineering inventions of great interest. He must have
graduated from a top engineering University in the US when I implied
that in some unknown manner that he graduated from some average
university after studying at Wesleyan University. Never judge a book
by its cover! His inventions were in military engineering and
quite impressive to me as a veterinarian. Actually if you think of it,
his inventions to protect naval ships from small terrorist ships
ramming with explosives are the equivalent of antibodies (with spiked
attachments) fighting against antigens (foreign invaders like bacteria
or terrorist)! |